“If you go into all of these buildings, pipes are broken, heat ain’t working, rats and roaches are infested. It’s more than this building collapsing.” That’s how one former resident of 1321 Flatbush Avenue described the building in the aftermath of its collapse on Wednesday, November 11.
The remains of the facade are a harrowing site, offering a glimpse into the inhabitants’ ordinary routines before they were violently interrupted—half a staircase, a closet full of clothes, and a vanity set with clothing piled atop it.
Among the eight victims who lost their lives were nine-year-old Nicole Daniela Salvada Rodriguez and her ten-year-old cousin, Kevin Santiago Reyes Gonzalez. The two children were spending Veteran’s Day together, enjoying time off from school.
Another victim was 22-year-old construction worker Gabriel Ariolfo Siguencia Yupa, who arrived in New York City just a month ago. He reportedly worked overtime at the jobsite next door to earn extra money for his wife and four-year-old son in Ecuador. Gabriel and his coworker, Jose Luis Cagana Cosquillo, also a young father to a four-year-old boy, were killed at the excavation site. Cosquillo’s wife was nine-months pregnant with their second child.
The eight deaths, alongside the 18 others who were injured, are a cruel testament to the hazardous conditions for workers in the capital of capitalism.
Reports about 1321 Flatbush Avenue reveal how precarious housing can be for New York workers. Unsafe electrical wiring, inoperable fire sprinklers, missing smoke detectors, water outages, bed bug infestations dating back to 1972—these are but a few of the building’s 98 open housing code violations.
Its infamous landlord, Olufemi Falade, has appeared no less than six times on the NYC Public Advocate’s Worst Landlord Watchlist over the last decade. In 2006, he was even jailed for not fixing some 1,800 violations across his properties—“an extremely rare penalty for a landlord” in the words of the right-wing New York Post.
Of course, fines and violations are just the “cost of doing business” for New York’s corporate landlords, which own 89% of the city’s residential rental units. It’s cheaper to pay the fine and ignore the problem.
Real estate developers have the same contempt for workers’ lives. Robert Fischman and Judy Swimer, who own the excavation site next to 1321 Flatbush Ave, were issued a stop-work order by the city’s Department of Buildings in March. Like the landlords, they shrugged off the Department’s fines, neglecting to install overhead protection to shield surrounding buildings from debris. In May, the Department of Buildings lifted the stop-work order after Fischman and Swimer paid a tidy $15,000—small change considering the nearly $4 million they spent buying the land alone.
After the collapse, further reporting revealed that the developers had proceeded to build the foundations for a nine-story complex starting in September, whereas the city had only reviewed and approved a three-story apartment building. This is a common practice among developers to avoid municipal oversight and hasten project timelines, since a larger structure would have required an onsite inspector.
In lieu of properly shoring up the neighboring 1321 Flatbush building, a five-foot dirt pile topped with concrete was packed against the wall. “That’s like Third-world stuff,” one of the injured construction workers said. The same worker claimed he didn’t speak out for fear of losing his job.
Under capitalism, the safety of residents, workers, and local communities is entirely subordinate to profits. As a result, tragedies like the one on Flatbush Avenue are certain to reoccur. A similar disaster was barely averted at Pfizer’s former Manhattan headquarters in July, while the “deteriorating” Brooklyn-Queens Expressway is in danger of catastrophic failure. But what are a few workers’ lives thrown into the excavation pit to the class enemy, who are too busy worshiping at the altar of capital?

