Nine months ago, Zohran Mamdani was sworn in as mayor of New York City. He is now a national political figure. Some even described Zohran as a “kingmaker” after a wave of DSA candidates won Democratic primaries with his endorsement this summer.
These electoral results would have been unthinkable 15 years ago. Thanks to decades of capitalist decline, millions of Americans are disgusted with the political establishment, looking for alternatives, and increasingly see socialism—and even communism—as viable options.
Ruling-class attacks
Alarmed by this change in public opinion, the ruling class wasted no time in attacking Zohran and the DSA.
Trump called the DSA “the most serious threat to our country since its existence” and an “uncontrollable form of cancer” that will destroy the US.
The Democratic establishment also took shots at DSA. A wing of the party is churning out interviews and op-eds about the need to purge democratic socialists from the party. Jamie Metzl, a member of Clinton’s State Department and Democratic strategist said:
The DSA poses a fundamental threat to the Democratic Party and to the nation as a whole. Based on their own platform, they are working to undermine our society, our economy, and our form of government organization, including our constitution.
Zohran faced similar media attacks during his mayoral campaign, which have only intensified now that he’s in office. The New York Post, a right-wing rag owned by Rupert Murdoch, covers him obsessively, publishing dozens of articles a week scrutinizing his every move.
Attacks on Zohran aren’t limited to slanders in the capitalist press. The ruling class actively aims to block him from implementing his agenda. When Zohran announced a pied-à-terre tax on luxury second homes, property owners immediately filed a lawsuit. Grocery store owners also filed an anti-trust lawsuit to block his plan to open city-owned grocery stores.
Another wing of the Democratic Party, rather than attacking the DSA or Zohran head on, intends to pressure him and other DSA candidates behind closed doors under the guise of friendly advice. They say they’re excited for an “open conversation” with the newcomers about how to “achieve their shared vision.”
These backroom talks where Democrat politicians “teach” anti-establishment insurgents “how things really get done” are the most pernicious type of pressure. For the ruling class, this is a means of watering down already modest programs and forcing these officials to stay within bounds entirely acceptable to capitalism.
These attacks on Zohran and the DSA are a product of the weakness of American capitalism. With a ballooning national debt of $40 trillion, the ruling class needs to make cuts and attack the working class.
The capitalists don’t want workers to feel united, optimistic, and powerful—especially now. They know that even minor reforms could embolden workers and snowball into a broader struggle. They will do everything they can to stop the momentum behind DSA, prevent them from implementing their program, and turn excitement and optimism into demoralization and pessimism.
Class-independent politics
To stand up to this barrage of attacks and pressure, socialists need not only good intentions and a desire to fight, but also crystal clarity on our goals, strategy, and methods of fighting.
The socialist revolution will be the culmination of centuries of class struggle stretching back to the earliest days of capitalism. It can only be carried out by a mass movement of the working class.
Workers must become conscious of the fact that society is divided into two major classes with fundamentally opposed interests—the workers and capitalists. Every step forward for workers comes at the expense of the capitalists, and vice versa.
The capitalists are our class enemy, and they won’t give up without a fight. Only by relying on our own strength, methods, and organizations—free from the influence of the enemy class—can we wage a successful struggle against them.
Workers will draw these conclusions from their own experience as the class struggle develops. The role of communists is to raise the working class’s confidence and unity, accelerating the process by which workers become conscious of the class divide and the necessity of socialism.
In short: everything that we do, including our approach to elections and holding office, is subordinate to the effort to sharpen the consciousness and independence of the working class.
Without this method, even the most well-intentioned socialists will end up trying to appease both sides of the class divide, which will inevitably result in carrying out the interests of our class enemy.
Zohran’s first nine months
Zohran’s approval rating sits at 58%—higher than Trump, the Democrats, and the Republicans. In his first nine months, he implemented a two-year rent freeze for rent-stabilized apartments and a pied-à-terre tax on luxury second homes. He also released plans for pilot programs to expand public childcare and open city-owned grocery stores.
Zohran has clashed with the ruling class several times already. To many, it seems that he’s winning the fight.
But looking at his tenure from the point of view of the broader class struggle reveals several areas where Zohran has already conceded ground to the ruling class. This ultimately stems from his lack of clarity on the question of class independence.
His pied-à-terre tax is a useful example.
In April, Zohran released a video celebrating the new tax titled, “Happy Tax Day, New York. We’re taxing the rich.” Standing outside of the $238 million penthouse of billionaire hedge fund CEO Ken Griffin, he singled out Griffin and his second home as the type of person and property that would now be taxed in order to fund an expanded public childcare program.
The video quickly caused uproar among the city’s elite. Real estate executive Steven Roth whined:
I consider the phrase “tax the rich” … when spit out with anger and contempt by politicians both here and across the country, to be just as hateful as some disgusting racial slurs and even the phrase, “from the river to the sea” … The rich, whom the politicians are targeting, started with nothing, are the epitome of the American dream … They should be praised and thanked.
Property owners immediately challenged the tax in the courts. It remains to be seen whether it will be implemented.
Nevertheless, aiming his fire at the city’s most parasitic elements has proved popular. Millions of workers and young people feel that Zohran is a mayor who is finally acting in their interests.
The billionaires’ outrageous backlash against the tax gave Zohran a perfect opportunity to continue the offensive. For example, rather than halting in the face of the lawsuits against the tax, he could say that the homes of those who refuse to pay the tax will be taken into public ownership and used to house the city’s tens of thousands of homeless people.
Instead, a Zohran spokesman responded to the backlash with conciliation: “Mayor Mamdani wants all New Yorkers to succeed. That includes business owners and entrepreneurs … It also includes Ken Griffin, who is a major employer in our city and a powerful figure in our economy.”
Then, in an attempt to win favor from Wall Street, Zohran announced the creation of a “Business Advisory Council,” composed of billionaires and CEOs who will regularly meet with him. Zohran justified the council by stating:
The doors of City Hall are always open to New York’s business leaders, and I look forward to welcoming their experience and strategic guidance as we build a stronger, more dynamic economy.
Rather than taking the opportunity to go on the offensive, he instead tried to placate the very billionaires that he had “offended” with his video.
“Worker Power”
In September, Zohran created the “Office of Worker Power.” While this was popular with his supporters, the scope of the office is minimal. It mainly aims to make workers aware of their rights by holding public meetings and workshops.
The existence of both the Office of Worker Power and the Business Advisory Council show that rather than seeing himself as a workers’ leader, Zohran wants to be a mayor for “all New Yorkers”—an impossible task in a society divided into classes.
Despite Zohran’s intentions, any program he implements will be paid for either by the working class or the capitalist class. There is no other option.
A real fight against the billionaires has to begin by recognizing this fundamental class antagonism, boldly adopting an “us versus them” stance, and dropping the attempts to curry favor with the ruling class.
Reforms paid out of the bosses’ pockets will provoke fierce resistance from the ruling class. Instead of trying to negotiate with the class enemy, he should rely on his massive base of support among the city’s workers. Only by organizing and mobilizing this base to fight through mass demonstrations, protests, and strikes can real reforms be won.
“Dangerous precedent”
New York’s “business leaders” should have zero influence over a politician claiming to represent the interests of the working class. But the pressure they exert over Zohran was evident in his handling of a recent bill passed by the New York City Council and backed by the United Federation of Teachers, which would give paraprofessionals in public schools a $10,000 bonus.
During his campaign, Zohran backed the bill. But the very same day it passed, his administration filed a lawsuit to block it.
City Hall argued that the bill violated labor laws and would set a “dangerous precedent” of unions getting pay raises outside the established collective bargaining procedures. In other words: they don’t want public sector workers to get ideas about demanding bonuses when the city is already strapped for cash.
The move got Zohran some unusual praise in the bourgeois media, including a favorable editorial in the New York Post:
“Kudos to Mamdani for eating his campaign promise to support the bonus bill … Mamdani’s courage here might even signal a willingness to stand firm in the coming round of contract talks with every city union; he doesn’t owe his office to them, after all.”
This episode shows that Zohran does not understand his role in the broader class struggle. He’s acting not as a workers’ representative, but as a bourgeois politician who has a legal responsibility to balance the NYC budget. He sees the paraprofessionals not as fellow workers engaged in the class struggle, but as a line item in the budget. Since the city “can’t afford” to give them bonuses, he files a lawsuit against them.
The only way for workers to win higher wages and better conditions is to wage a struggle outside of the bounds set by bourgeois labor law. Rather than fearing the “dangerous precedent,” a socialist mayor should argue for breaking with the established procedures.
Zohran could point out that there is plenty of money on Wall Street to give a significant pay raise not only to paraprofessionals, but to all teachers, city workers, and workers in the private sector. To do that, he would need to recognize that the billionaires won’t give up their riches without a fight, and that we need to organize a struggle against them through mass, collective action.
This method would not win him any praise from the bourgeois press. It would provoke a revolt of his Business Advisory Council. But it would also massively raise the authority of socialism in the eyes of the working class.
What’s next?
This won’t be the last time the budgetary needs of the capitalist state clash against the interest of the workers.
Next year, the city will again have a budget deficit of around $6 billion, which Zohran is legally obligated to fill. This will coincide with the negotiation of new contracts with several public sector unions.
If he sticks with the method of balancing the budget within the confines of the law, there will only be one option: make the working class pay for the deficit. City workers’ wages and benefits will either remain stagnant, be lowered, or be increased through taxes on other workers or cuts to other public spending.
Zohran is already signaling retreats on other campaign promises. He acknowledged that free buses are no longer on the agenda. His childcare program won’t go into effect for another six years.
Nevertheless, Zohran is still incredibly popular. Most people see his backtracking as unfortunate, but forgivable, one-off missteps. But these retreats are not just personal mistakes. They are the result of an incorrect political outlook and lack of class-independent politics. Without adopting a completely different method, he will not be able to resist the pressure and maneuvers of the ruling class.
Eventually, it will become clear that he won’t deliver on his campaign promises, and a large section of his supporters will grow disillusioned. It is impossible to say how long this will take, but it will happen.
This should be a warning to all of the DSA candidates who have won recent primaries. Simply having more DSA members elected won’t translate their ability to fight the ruling class. Unless they are willing to break with the established methods of bourgeois politics, their momentum will eventually turn to disillusionment and demoralization—exactly what the ruling class is hoping for.
Break with the Democrats
A key part of DSA’s strategy is to run candidates as Democrats. Many in DSA see the Democratic Party as a neutral vessel whose ballot line can help them get elected.
But the reality is that both the Democrats and Republicans are bourgeois institutions—they are funded by, controlled by, and defend the interests of the capitalist class.
Running within the Democratic Party implies, incorrectly, that a wing of the ruling class is closer to “our side.” It blurs the class line instead of sharpening it.
It also ties DSA to the policies of the ruling-class parties. At the moment, the Democrats are in the minority. But if they gain a majority in Congress and win the presidency in 2028, they will govern in the interests of the capitalist class. By remaining in the class enemy’s party, Zohran and other DSA members will share political responsibility for the reactionary policies the Democrats implement when they return to power.
Running as Democrats may help DSA candidates get elected this cycle. But in the long run, they’re setting themselves up to be associated with austerity, war, and imperialism—rather than taking the opportunity to massively accelerate the class struggle by forming a mass workers’ party.
Already, large sections of the working class have correctly written off the Democrats. An increasing number of young workers associate the Democrats with the genocide in Gaza and a failure to combat Trump. This means that DSA will be associated not only with the policies of the Democrats, but with the entire rotten party establishment.
If a figure like Zohran or an organization like the DSA broke with the ruling-class parties and formed a class-independent alternative, American politics would be completely transformed. Both the Democrats and Republicans would take serious hits, as workers who currently support one of the capitalist parties—alongside workers who don’t engage in politics at all—flocked to the new party.
This would be a massive step forward for the class struggle. It would redraw the dividing line in American politics from Democrat vs. Republican to worker vs. capitalist. Rather than being associated with the hated establishment parties, socialism would be seen as something fundamentally against them and for us.
There has never been a better time to go on the offensive against the Democratic Party. They are hated and weak. But instead of moving away from the Democrats, Zohran is moving closer to them. In a recent interview with the New York Times, Zohran doubled down on his Democrat credentials. “My party is the Democratic Party,” he said, before explaining the things that make him “proud to be a Democrat.”
Once again, Zohran showed his lack of clarity about the fundamental class divide in society. He thinks there is a wing of the ruling class that is “better” or “more friendly” to workers. But collaborating with the ruling class means losing ground to them. In the long term, this will only discredit him in the eyes of workers.
Way forward
After decades of relative lull in the socialist movement, the recent resurgence in the popularity of socialism and communism represent a massive reawakening of the American working class and a turning point in the class struggle.
Only by adopting a bold, class-independent strategy can socialists capitalize on this momentum. This requires a complete break with both parties of the ruling class and a fight for reforms through class struggle, rather than cozying up to billionaires.
Using these methods, a real struggle against capitalism and for a better world is entirely achievable.

