Strategy without tactics is the slowest route to victory.
Tactics without strategy is the noise before defeat.
—Sun Tzu, The Art of War
Mutual aid has become a major buzzword of 2026, both in the streets and online. In our daily recruitment activity, RCA comrades report being asked more frequently than ever: “What do you think of mutual aid?”
Google searches for “mutual aid” jumped by 400% during January of this year. This record peak coincided with the mass movement against ICE in Minnesota. The previous record was during the 2020 pandemic, when daily searches briefly quadrupled compared to the average over the previous decade.
It’s also popping up in the mainstream press. The New York Times has mentioned “mutual aid” in over 630 articles since the start of this year—more than in the previous 36 years combined.
The buzz around this term is, quite literally, a sign of the times. We’re living in a crisis-ridden era that is pushing people to ask: What do we do about it? How do we come together and change things? The events of 2020 itself—a mass health catastrophe and an unprecedented nationwide social explosion—foreshadowed the kind of decade we were stepping into. Millions of people, cooped up in the Covid lockdown, suddenly went from doomscrolling in isolation to taking part in the largest street demonstrations in US history.
The scenes in Minneapolis: 2020 and 2026
What did “mutual aid” look like in the summer of 2020? It meant taking part in a mass movement: linking up with neighbors who normally never interacted, collecting and distributing supplies like masks, water, and food to demonstrators.
Some threw themselves into the protest movement, forming street medic teams to attend to victims of tear gas, rubber bullets, or pepper spray. Others formed legal defense networks, collecting funds to bail out demonstrators swept up in mass arrests. A few even picked up arms and formed neighborhood patrols—a bold step to defend working-class communities in the face of reactionary paramilitary groups, out-of-town looters and provocateurs, and the threat of police terror itself.
Each of these efforts drew in the direct participation, creativity, and energy of regular people who felt compelled to get on their feet and take action. When the mass movement ebbed, so did most of the ad hoc networks that had sprouted from it, leaving little in their wake: group chats, new acquaintances, and the powerful vivid memories of having lived through a historic mass movement.

What did “mutual aid” look like in the summer of 2020? It meant taking part in a mass movement. / Image: Tony Webster, Wikimedia Commons
Then, for the second time in less than six years, Minneapolis became ground zero of another historic movement. Invaded by roving bands of violent paramilitaries deployed by the federal government, the city fought back with methods of mass self-organization surpassing even the most advanced days of 2020.
Just days after an ICE agent murdered Renée Good, a community meeting was called at Whittier Elementary School in South Minneapolis. Turnout wildly surpassed the organizers’ expectations. People swarmed in from all directions, filling every large room on the campus to capacity.
RCA comrades in attendance reported the mood: “This movement seems to be picking up where George Floyd left off five years ago. The momentum towards neighborhood defense committees is far stronger than ever before. There is also growing enthusiasm for a statewide general strike on January 23.”
In what would quickly become a tradition of this movement, the crowd was instructed to “find your neighbors” and form group chats on the Signal messenger app for further coordination. Hundreds of such Signal groups were formed at similar gatherings that mushroomed across the city in the subsequent weeks.
The encrypted chats became communication hubs for a citywide frenzy of activity. “Commuters” patrolled the streets, tailing ICE convoys, reporting on their movements in real time, and summoning crowds to converge whenever agents attempted an arrest. Parents guarded school zones, standing watch in shifts throughout the day. Volunteer teams went from business to business encouraging workers to make rapid-response contingency plans in the event of a raid on their block.
Neighborhood assemblies frequently gathered dozens or hundreds of local residents to discuss updates and plan next steps. Food banks, overwhelmed with more than they could manage, actually had to ask people to stop donating. Tenant unions raised funds to help cover rent for families that had to hide out to keep safe, or had lost a breadwinner to an ICE arrest.
A grassroots call for a day of action on January 23 gained momentum, forcing the local labor leaders to give it tacit support—though they stopped short of calling for a real work stoppage. Still, the resulting de facto general strike shut down over 800 businesses, schools, and other public institutions, while a triumphant procession of around 100,000 people marched through the city in subfreezing temperatures. The mass movement forced the Trump administration to retreat, calling off Operation Metro Surge and withdrawing most of the federal agents from the Twin Cities.
This was a major moral victory, but an incomplete one. Months later, protesters are being detained and charged for their actions in January. ICE maintains a limited presence and has continued to detain people locally, while nationwide, ICE arrests continue to increase. The mutual aid groups report burnout and dwindling funds, as contributions dry up from working-class families whose own finances are stretched thin.
An orchestra without a conductor
Though the mass media scarcely covered these efforts, the inspiring scenes percolated through social media. The fact that web searches for “mutual aid” spiked so suddenly and dramatically against this backdrop of events suggests that some saw the struggle as an example of mutual aid in action. At the very least, it suggests people were raising questions of strategy and tactics—is mutual aid a way for me to get active and support this movement?
When thousands of people come together to coordinate efforts of mass resistance, is this a form of “mutual aid”? This is a fair question. Broadly speaking, every mass struggle depends on widespread cooperation, often drawing on the creativity and ingenuity of ordinary people. Marxists would not use the vague term “mutual aid” to describe this phenomenon, but the similarities are worth examining.
In 1934, Minneapolis was the center of yet another inspiring mass struggle—the historic citywide general strike led by Teamsters Local 574, which was, in turn, led by the Communist League of America (CLA). This was one of those rare occasions when an episode of the class war found the clear-eyed, determined leadership it deserved. The Marxist cadres of the CLA served as the crucial general staff.
The strikers elected delegates to a central strike committee that established a physical headquarters as the command center for all operations. They innovated the tactic of the “flying pickets”—mobile detachments deployed to head off scab trucks. They coordinated strike funds, gathered food, supplies, and volunteers to staff a kitchen that fed thousands of strikers and their families throughout the 37-day struggle.
When police began cracking heads, they responded by forming defensive fighting detachments equipped with makeshift blackjacks, and built a rudimentary hospital wing to treat victims of police brutality. They even established a reconnaissance network, enlisting the help of youngsters on bicycles to gather intelligence and report the movements of scabs and cops back to HQ.
Throughout these efforts, the strike committee published a daily paper, The Organizer, to broadcast news of the struggle, counter the official propaganda of the pro-business media, and win broader sympathy.
The 1934 General Strike was one of the greatest American strike victories of the twentieth century. It was also a symphony of mass cooperation vaguely reminiscent of the scenes of volunteer networks acting in unison in the struggle against ICE—but on a much more highly orchestrated level. The glaring difference between the general strike of 1934 and the one in 2026 was the presence of a political leadership capable of centrally coordinating the efforts. One orchestra had a conductor; the other didn’t.
Both movements had the active support of thousands of ordinary people, willing to contribute their time, energy, resources, and creativity toward a collective struggle. But in the absence of a central headquarters, an elected strike committee, or an accountable leadership of any sort, the movement this January was left to improvise day by day, expressing its confusion at each step. “What are we even doing here? What’s next? We need some kind of strategy!”—sentiments like these echoed out at each impromptu neighborhood meeting. As one comrade put it, “the leadership vacuum was outrageously clear.”

The glaring difference between the general strike of 1934 and the one in 2026 was the presence of a political leadership capable of centrally coordinating the efforts. One orchestra had a conductor; the other didn’t. / Image: WBUR Boston’s NPR News Station, Flickr
The ambiguity of “mutual aid”
When the average left-leaning person on the street asks the RCA for our take on mutual aid, our first instinct should be to put the question back to them: what exactly do you mean by mutual aid? In a year like 2026, it’s possible that behind this phrase is a desire to get organized for a Minneapolis-style mass struggle. But more often than not, the appeal of mutual aid reflects an abstract desire for concrete action; an urge to “do something” tangible without any further link to a thought-out strategy.
Doomerism and a sense of societal decline are in the air. People feel the urgency to act. As communists, we’re highly attuned to this sentiment. But our job is to direct this urgency toward a revolutionary strategy for the overthrow of capitalism—and not just “action” for the sake of feeling like at least we’re doing something.
Oftentimes, arguments for mutual aid take a moralistic form: people are suffering—we need to help them. The sentimental justification for mutual aid is not hard to understand. Helping people in need isn’t just a noble pursuit, it’s rooted deeply in our collectivist evolutionary origins as a species. Contrary to the antisocial conditioning we receive under capitalism, it is far more natural for humans to show concern for one another’s wellbeing than to turn away and ignore suffering.
Peter Kropotkin, the anarchist who coined the term “mutual aid,” analyzed the role of human cooperation in prehistoric societies in his 1902 book, Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution. Unlike today’s anarchists, however, he never suggested that this was a political tactic for eliminating the problems caused by class society.
Typically, the more insistent and thought-out the argument for mutual aid, the more it bears the hallmarks of a pseudo-radical, middle-class outlook. Dean Spade became the modern guru of mutual aid in the post-pandemic era with his 2020 book, Mutual Aid: Building Solidarity During This Crisis (and the Next). Here’s how he defines the term:
More and more ordinary people are feeling called to respond in their communities, creating bold and innovative ways to share resources and support vulnerable neighbors. This survival work, when done in conjunction with social movements demanding transformative change, is called mutual aid … and it produces social spaces where people grow new solidarities. At its best, mutual aid actually produces new ways of living where people get to create systems of care and generosity that address harm and foster wellbeing.
“Survival work,” “producing social spaces where people grow new solidarities,” “new ways of living,” and “systems of care and generosity.” This kind of squishy, postmodern language should raise the hackles of any self-respecting communist. We reject this attempt to dress up love-thy-neighbor sentimentality as some kind of new-age political radicalism. If someone wants to feel good about helping others, that may be a wholesome way to make friends in a social setting—but don’t sell leisure as a way to change the world.
The Marxist worldview rests on the bedrock of philosophical materialism. Translated into class-struggle strategy, this can only mean class politics. The working class is the only social force capable of ending capitalism, by seizing the immense productive capabilities of modern industry and putting them to rational use. We will end hunger when the agriculture, logistics, wholesale, and retail networks are under our collective democratic control. We’ll end homelessness when the private real-estate market is converted into a publicly owned plan for quality social housing.
The technical means already exist for a world of superabundance. What’s holding us back from realizing this potential is private ownership of the means of production and the nation-state; not makeshift networks for the working poor to share crumbs amongst ourselves. We need socialism; not “survival work” under capitalism. We need a revolutionary party; not “systems of care and generosity.”
Why not both?—some will inevitably ask. Because our lifetimes are short enough as it is, and the time and energy of revolutionaries are limited. The precious time spent preparing for success in the brief window of a revolutionary situation should not be whittled down and diverted by projects designed to ease a middle-class conscience.
A class-struggle strategy
What was missing in Minneapolis this January was an organization capable of providing leadership for the working class, as the cadres of the Communist League of America did in 1934. What would this have looked like?

The largest employers—the Minneapolis International Airport, the banks, the corporate headquarters, the retail chains—could have been brought to a grinding halt from within. / Image: Lorie Shaull, Flickr
It would have begun with a well-organized network of hundreds or even thousands of trained revolutionary activists with roots in all the key industries, the largest workplaces, including communications and logistics, and embedded in all the working-class neighborhoods. Pulling in the same direction, agitating on the same key, they would have campaigned tirelessly to link up the neighborhood assemblies—Signal chats included—into a citywide strike committee made up of delegates elected from every workplace and neighborhood.
They would have established a media operation highlighting every instance of brutality by the ICE thugs and exposing the hypocrisy of the federal government. The central headquarters would have deployed teams of organizers to build up a reliable base of support within the unions, and conducted a campaign for a genuine work stoppage, instead of the vague suggestion put out by the labor leaders to take a sick day on January 23. The largest employers—the Minneapolis International Airport, the banks, the corporate headquarters, the retail chains—could have been brought to a grinding halt from within.
The stream of generous donations that overwhelmed food banks could have turned into a centrally coordinated strike fund for keeping every working-class family fed for the duration of the struggle. Citywide tenants unions could have dealt with the landlords collectively, withholding rent and imposing a moratorium on evictions from below.
At each step, the success of these tactics would have depended not only on the technical degree of organization, but on the political level of the cadres—the clarity of their arguments, and their ability to make a compelling case for why all workers should organize in solidarity.
The scenes that played out in practice prove that the mass of the population was behind the movement. There was no lack of willingness to take part and contribute. Only a farsighted and accountable leadership was lacking—a force capable of providing a lead and raising the confidence of the working class in its own strength and self-organization.
This is the lesson of Minneapolis, and the answer to the question of how revolutionaries should be spending our finite time and energy. We don’t know whether Minneapolis will be the site of the next social explosion, but we can be certain more events of this type are on the horizon. The more time we devote to recruiting, educating, and training cadres ahead of these events, the greater our chances of success.

